@MontyB: the way I explained it, my initial gut-feeling of Nietzsche dislike was way more primitive than yours, because it had occurred even before I read anything written by him or even before reading on wikipedia about him...all I knew was that I thought he had written that thing "God is dead", which seemed to me more sensationalistic in style rather than scholarly, plus I knew, by having read before about Hannah Arendt's unfortunate encounter with real Nazi party member Martin Heidegger, that this Heidegger had publicly said he admired Nietzsche...so you can see why I reacted just like when faced with some high-school class group misbehavior or perceived injustice...at the level of a rumor based "guilty by association" verdict.
I will furthermore admit I have never actually read ANY philosophy book written by a professional philosopher...I never even managed to get very far with
Jostein Gaarder 's "
Sophie's World", (which is, IMHO, having read about 1/3 of it, a high-school level somewhat romanticized history of philosophy), even though it was recommended to me by a person whose critical judgment I trust very much and who knows me very well.
It was only when a Norwegian reputable professional writer and translator who had actually read Nietzsche, and who is most certainly NOT some form of nihilist or "anarchist", said to me that I didn't know what I was talking about, that, thus shamed, I started reading about Nietzsche on wikipedia, and then I found out about his mental illness, then I found out about OTHERS who seemed to be quite spread out on the political spectrum said they liked what he wrote, or at least gave him some time and serious consideration...including, as I said, some French left style political philosophers, Gen. de Gaulle, who certainly was not left, or Mr. President Teddy Roosevelt, who may have been a liberal, but he was an
American Progressive Era liberal), Mr. President Richard Nixon, who was an American
Old Cold War Era
conservative...so, then I truly had to ethically take that into consideration myself...
...although, quite candidly, after having expended so much effort on only ONE philosopher, (and there are SO MANY !), I still most certainly wish that most, if not all, philosophy books come with a little cautionary warning, (like the pillow tags !), saying something along the lines of:
1. this is the abstract opinion of one philosopher, and must not be considered as generally explanatory for the real world around us;
2. it is better before reading the book to read both the
Preface of this book, plus another independent source about the life and history of that particular philosopher who wrote it, in order to understand the exact historical, political, social, and geographic context it was written in;
3. it is highly advisable NOT to use illegal drugs while reading or thinking about philosophy;
4. if anyone, while reading this book starts feeling very depressed or starts to think about harming themselves or anyone else, please immediately call this 800-"Hotline" type number, or the Emergency 911 (in the USA + Canada)/112 (in Europe, up to the old
USSR borders) number for immediate assistance.