A Can of Man
Je suis aware
I checked the Wikipedia article and it's making a lot more sense actually.
But still if you look at the problem in a slightly different way, or if you word it in a different way with the actions being virtually identical, the explanation doesn't seem to hold as well.
For example let's try this.
You picked door 1 and the host opened door 3 revealing the goat.
You leave and a friend who has no knowledge of the 3rd door shows up and has to pick between door 1 and door 2. That's 50/50 isn't it? Situation is almost virtually the same.
But still if you look at the problem in a slightly different way, or if you word it in a different way with the actions being virtually identical, the explanation doesn't seem to hold as well.
For example let's try this.
You picked door 1 and the host opened door 3 revealing the goat.
You leave and a friend who has no knowledge of the 3rd door shows up and has to pick between door 1 and door 2. That's 50/50 isn't it? Situation is almost virtually the same.