If the China communist army attack Taiwan, would the west countries protect Taiwan? - Page 5




 
--
 
April 5th, 2013  
udaka
 
You mean American help the Taiwanese is fear Taiwan developed atomic bomb blackmail American?

So about 30 countries in the world had ability develope atomic bomb. So the USA must give many financial assistance to these countries. For prevent they developed nukes blackmail American?

So the USA is a superpower or a sickman?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Number0038
Why You Should Care About Taiwan


I think this opinion is worth to read about current Sino-Formosa-US relation.
What if US abandoned defense pact with taiwan for few chinese bucks?


To Save Our Economy, Ditch Taiwan

This opinion
"To Save US Economy, Ditch Taiwan" sounds good idea for many people.

But,result will be catastrophic.
Nobody won't welcome Nuclear Armed Taiwan,Vietnam,Thailand,or Singapore.
April 6th, 2013  
BritinAfrica
 
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Eden
Soldiers do what they are told to.
Not if its an illegal order.
April 10th, 2013  
Easy-8
 
 
If China invades Taiwan it will basically be a super Falklands War.
--
April 10th, 2013  
LeEnfield
 
 
I just hope that we would stay out of it
April 12th, 2013  
udaka
 
Presume the American support Taiwan is fear Taiwanese developed the Atomic bombs blackmail them. That I can bet the American won't send troops save Taiwanese when Chinese invade Taiwan. Because even Taiwan test atomic bomb sucessfully, For example Uranium bomb or plutonium bomb.But compare the huge nuclear arsenal of China,the atomic bombs of Taiwan just like pistol,the CCP had machine -gun. Of coure, the Ameircan will more fear China than Taiwanese.

About more than 30 countries in the world had ability develope atomic bomb.


If the American assistance Taiwanese is fear Taiwanese research the atomic bombs blackmail them ,that is tell the world--- The USA isn't a super power,it just a sickman. The KIM BOY is on the correct way, north korean use nuke blackmail more moneys `foods and assistance from USA and South korean.

The other countries follow the example use nukes or developed nuclear weapons blackmail American,ask USA give them more financial and other assistance.----- like China,India,Pakistan, Turkey, Kazakhstan, Egypt, Iran,South Africa,Argentina, Brazil,Japan,South korean,Vietnam,Tajikistan, Turkmenistan...........




Quote:
Originally Posted by udaka
You mean American help the Taiwanese is fear Taiwan developed atomic bomb blackmail American?

So about 30 countries in the world had ability develope atomic bomb. So the USA must give many financial assistance to these countries. For prevent they developed nukes blackmail American?

So the USA is a superpower or a sickman?
April 12th, 2013  
D.J
 
Two historical examples illustrate the improbability of an amphibious assault on Taiwan. The 1944 Normandy invasion (which took 176,000 troops, 10,000 aircraft, 136 warships, and 3,000 landing craft) and Operation Causeway, the aborted U.S. plan to invade Taiwan during World War II, using a massive 450,000 troops.

You must carry around. 250.000 troops across between 80 and 100 miles of sea.
Secondly, it is very doubtful that you could mass the number of modern sophisticated aircraft required to provide the local air superiority necessary over the Taiwan Strait during the operation. The Chinese forces remain essentially a 1970s organisation with too many men, very little really modern equipment and a continuing lack of an ability to mount effective combined operations.

Taiwan has about 375,000 ready forces and over 1.5 million reserves. The standing army has 240,000 troops with more effective equipment than the Chinese. But the real deterrent is the US Seventh Fleet. But it will never happen because the economic cost would be very high, probably a lot more than the Chinese could afford and your Government knows it.


April 15th, 2013  
BuskyChowChow
 
Udaka I think your only goal here is to gain an insight into why us westerners are willing to defend Taiwan, and the honest answer is principal. Taiwan has been independent of mainland China's rule since 1949 and it is going to stay that way seeing as only 4.5% of the population want reunification.

Taiwan is democratic, China is communist. This is why the west, in particular USA want it to remain independent. The reverse is the case with North Korea. What benefit does that country serve to China? Nothing. It is just a Communist barrier between a close ally of USA, south Korea, and China.

You ask why USA would defend Taiwan? Why don't you look at why China is defending North Korea first and try to justify that.


Your country would be incredibly unwise to try an invasion as that would only result in total destruction of Taiwan, hence defeating the purpose of obtaining the country to begin with. Taiwan's military sophistication is more than sufficient to hold off a Chinese invasion until the US intervenes.

On top of this, if the US then imposes sanctions on China, which it would, China's trade would plummet and a famine could be a high possibility.

It is obvious from your posts that you feel an invasion of Taiwan would be justifiable, but I as a Westerner would disagree highly. The people of Taiwan are happy to be separate to China, they are happy with a democracy and since the late 70's, Taiwan has never made any move to attack or in any way cause an incident with China. Who are the Chinese people to decide that Taiwan is theirs now? You have no right to invade the country.


Another post earlier mentioned the idea of people dying for countries which aren't their own, to which you scoffed and cited Hollywood. But this is the major difference between the Chinese and the West. Out here we do believe in a right and wrong, so highly that we are willing to give our lives to protect soil which isn't even our birthright.

I would be more than willing to die fighting to protect Taiwan from an invading, aggressor Chinese army.
April 18th, 2013  
udaka
 
You claim you willing die for Taiwan? Good ,very good! I hope you will fulfill what your promise! Because I know these white guys very good at braging and lying,and very good at intimidate the people of the world. Even the American betrayed the ally who save their ass in world war 2.
Suddenly a white guy jump up claim he will die for Taiwanese. It make me pleasantly and surprised. But I suggest you battle to dead in the war! Because the CCP won't accept any POWS at war. They will bloody killed abused POWS in war like Japanese in ww2.No matter the pilots and soldiers.Are you ready ,dude?

Before you intimidate beat down China. I think you advise your army take
the little North korean down at first.
Now dude,it is time to you die for liberate North korean people from the evil KIM boy. If you could not find the way to North korean. You can ask the C130 drop you there.

And dude ,I am very glad you eager to die in the battle,you can fulfill your wish right now. I suggest you join the rebels of Sylia, they are "liberate" the Sylia people from "evil" government. What a great career.!About 70000 peoeple die at the bloody war. The rebels will give you a AK47 or RPG. Are you ready buy a ticket of plane fly to Syria now?



Why the US took Japanese as ally?
Of course,the US will support Japs,
Yup ,because they very enjoyed the Japs bloody killed abuse them or insulted them." oh yeah, baby,oh yeah, baby",give me a good job! beat me,rape me, harder,harder,hit me face,kick my ass, torture me! I am very high. Oh,baby! insert my dirty hole!
" Oh yeah,baby,yeah, baby! yeah, baby!broke my leg,hit my face,rape me! I am very high.
The girls of white: "Oh, Japanese soldiers,u are so handsome,you are so men! we love you ,u are so brave,Wow, your genitalia so "big".

Oh, my honey! do you want play sex game? three to 1? or four to 1? Push your big "guns" into my dirty hole and sh!t hole!'




Quote:
Originally Posted by BuskyChowChow
Another post earlier mentioned the idea of people dying for countries which aren't their own, to which you scoffed and cited Hollywood. But this is the major difference between the Chinese and the West. Out here we do believe in a right and wrong, so highly that we are willing to give our lives to protect soil which isn't even our birthright.

I would be more than willing to die fighting to protect Taiwan from an invading, aggressor Chinese army.
April 18th, 2013  
D.J
 
I fear that the rice you eat in china have a high content of lead.
April 18th, 2013  
zhaldev
 
 
i guess he's the same micowe guy,who started the alien thread and now the Taiwan thing...Well....Chinese don't have the ball to start the war against Taiwan.
 


Similar Topics
"Tommy's Dictionary Of The Trenches" WWI
Why can't Taiwanese people accept their Chinese heritage?
China' army
Japanese military and politic -- Discussion and details.
How to stop China