AK: regular magazine vs. drum - Page 2




 
--
 
May 10th, 2011  
Prapor
 
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by A Can of Man
but 75 rounds means less reloading!! WOOOOOO!!!!
That is the idea, yes

And, for the record, I don't personally know any Black Diggers, though I have done dealings with them. Through mutual friends. That is how you do everything in this country.
May 12th, 2011  
Korean Seaboy
 
 
Ah, the PPSH. It's my favorite WWII gun, reliable even after almost 70 years. The North Koreans still use it you know.

From what I know, the PPSH had unmatched firepower, was incrediblely cheap. Although it frequently jammed and had reloading problems, it was nevertheless admired for its low recoil and the superior firepower.

From what I remember, the PPSH was made as a cheaper variant of the PPD (along with simpler parts), and was inspired from a Finnish submachine gun, the Suomi 31. It was the most widely used Soviet machine gun during WWII. An even cheaper version, the PPS was produced, but after the war.


These facts are admirable, but my personal atttachment to the PPSH is because of the drum magazine. I don't know why, but it makes the PPSH seem unique.
May 12th, 2011  
Prapor
 
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Korean Seaboy
Ah, the PPSH. It's my favorite WWII gun, reliable even after almost 70 years. The North Koreans still use it you know.

From what I know, the PPSH had unmatched firepower, was incrediblely cheap. Although it frequently jammed and had reloading problems, it was nevertheless admired for its low recoil and the superior firepower.

From what I remember, the PPSH was made as a cheaper variant of the PPD (along with simpler parts), and was inspired from a Finnish submachine gun, the Suomi 31. It was the most widely used Soviet machine gun during WWII. An even cheaper version, the PPS was produced, but after the war.


These facts are admirable, but my personal atttachment to the PPSH is because of the drum magazine. I don't know why, but it makes the PPSH seem unique.
Well, no, it wasn't unique per se.

First, the Americans already had the Thompson gun by then.

And second, there was also Dyogtarev's Machine Pistol, the PPD-40


PPDs are rarer to find than PPSHs.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PPD-40

Quote:
PPD-40 was too complicated and expensive to mass-produce, and although it was used in action in the initial stages of World War II, it was officially replaced by the superior and cheaper PPSh-41 by the end of 1941[2]. Approximately 90,000 PPDs were manufactured.
--
May 13th, 2011  
MikeP
 
 
Drums are heavy, unwieldy, slow to load, and cause wear to the locking area.
You would have heat issues with sustained use.

Stick mags can be loaded in seconds using strippers.

Spend some time in the Infantry and you get a whole different take on the weight issue.

I might carry one, but would not load myself down with several..
May 13th, 2011  
Korean Seaboy
 
 
Prapor: Yes I knew about the Thompson (yet didn't it use the regular magazine instead of a drum until the PPSH came in?). I also knew about the PPD, which I mentioned. Yet the reputation of the PPSH, and the love of it by Soviet soldiers, along with its wide use makes it unique. The fact that it is one of the few guns to use the drum adds more to its mystique
August 5th, 2011  
LeEnfield
 
 
MikeP ... has covered what I was going to say on this matter. With a drum you hose an area down hoping that you will some one, with a magazine you just might take a bit more time for an aimed shot. Still you have carry all this stuff on your back and there is often a limit that you can manage to carry.
August 6th, 2011  
5.56X45mm
 
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Prapor
I own a Kalashnikov myself, as do quite a few of my friends, patriots that we are

Recently, on advise from a trusted man I adapted my AK to use drums instead of regular 'horn' magazines. Many here are doing that. Here is why.

Most 'horns' available here are regular size, that carry 20 shots


A more rare 'extended horn' gets you 40.


But a drum

gives you 75!

Here's my AKM


What do you guys think? Drum or horn? Any AK owners here, or anyone who's ever fired one? Or other guns too. I've seen a M-16 with a drum not too long ago...

I own a AK Series Rifle. The Drum Magazine you have pictured is the same I have. It's made in Romania and is a copy of the Chinese RPK Drum.



Sorry for the crappy cell phone picture.

Anyways..... I have one drum, twenty 30rd mags, three 20rd mags, and three 40rd mags. The 40rd mags are quite common. They were made by the USSR for their RPKs. There is a Warsaw Pact designed drum mag but they're a little on the rare side. The 20rd mags were made by Hungary for the AMD-65 when issued to tank crews.

I got the drum mag for two reasons. One, they were on sale for cheap and two, they make a excellent tool for a break contact rifle. When I travel I take the AK with me with a drum mag and my three 40rd mags. Got plenty of power in a small package.

My plan is simple... use the drum and if that runs out pop in a standard mag.
August 7th, 2011  
KJ
 
 
For the AK5 the drum were all but useless.
The drummag often had feeding problems.
All it took were a slightly sloppy reload or snagging it on a brush and thus moving it a few mm and your weapon would malfunction.

We allready have the Minini for a light machinegun and have more use of the AK as what it was intended as, a carbine/assault rifle.

Furthermore I would rather carry more mags that I can spread out all over my pack (thus dispersing the weight) then hump for long distances lugging a heavy arsed drum in my hands.
A few hours of movement and the stamina requiered to carry a drum will start to effect your accuracy when you actually need to employ your weapon to maximum effect.. ie: hitting your target.

But it does look cool on them posing like a badass picture.

The PPSh is a different matter.
I know the finns went to great lengths to retrieve them of fallen enemies to employ them themselves as they outperformed their own weapons.

KJ sends..
August 8th, 2011  
84RFK
 
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by KJ
The PPSh is a different matter.
I know the finns went to great lengths to retrieve them of fallen enemies to employ them themselves as they outperformed their own weapons.

KJ sends..
Outperformed what and how?

OK, they outperformed the cyclic rate of a Moisin Nagant rifle, they had a slightly longer range than the 9mm. used in Suomi KP31, and they generally didn't jam up due to generous dimentions in the mechanism.

But personally I'd choose the Suomi KP31 over the PPSh anyway.

Might add that I have no experience what so ever with the Suom drum-magazine, only the "coffin-type" wich worked well for me.
August 9th, 2011  
Yossarian
 
 
Drum seems a great place to start, after that if your still in the heat, standard box mags from then all out.


But this thread does remind me of that particular incident in North Hollywood....

As for the morons involved... (Niether was on par with say Dillinger, also a user of drum magazines for era weapons) all I can say it I firmly believe, that it was a very innapropriate use of ammunition...

Just seems that a drum magazine seems for more impractical uses than for standard use on this type of service rifle...

Just my thoughts
 


Similar Topics
Springfield Sniper Rifle vs. K98 Sniper Rifle
Al-Qaida launches English propaganda magazine (AP)
Difference between light and regular infantry?
General Tommy Franks in Parade Magazine
Artillerymen Magazine from Fort Sill - Where Else?