Sherman vs T-34

[godofthunder9010]

In a 1 on 1 fight, who would win? We have equally skilled tank crews (of course).

What we find from history is that both of these tanks are largely overhyped, yet both are very capable. No upgraded versions BTW.

 

[Sea_Cadet]

T-34 would blow that sherman sky-high

 

[Kozzy Mozzy]

T-34, Sherman dies.

 

[godofthunder9010]

Based on how efficient Germany was at killing both types of tanks, they should actually be fairly close to equal. There are lots of other factors of course, so its hard to use that as a basis for judgement. I'd pick the T-34 myself. Much better design and its not standing up begging to be shot and killled quite like the Sherman is.

 

[Kozzy Mozzy]

Are you kidding? The T-34 was superior to all German tanks except the Tiger and King Tiger. It was cheap, reliable, good firepower, good armor, and good mobility.

 

[Aguy201]

T-34, hahaha i may exagerate a little but sherman v t-34 like firing AK-47 at a stealth bomber, or more likely an iraqi t-72 v a abram

 

[godofthunder9010]

Are you kidding? The T-34 was superior to all German tanks except the Tiger and King Tiger. It was cheap, reliable, good firepower, good armor, and good mobility.

That's very debatable -- you're forgetting the Panther and several other German models could have given the T-34 a run for their money. We're talking about the original T34, not the upgrade.

I have to be honest, I was mostly curious if anybody would actually vote for the Sherman and why.

 

[SHERMAN]

hmm, the T-34 was better, mainly as far as protection.

 

[Marksman]

T-34 totally,shermanwould be target pratice

 

[Doppleganger]

Before I can vote which version of the Sherman are we talking about?. It does make a difference. Aside from this the T-34 was a much superior tank design and in most cases it would beat a Sherman 1 v 1.

 

[godofthunder9010]

Only rule was no upgraded versions of either tank.

 

[rocco]

idf shermans with 105mm guns KTFO arab t-34

 

[SHERMAN]

like was just posted, no upgrades....and the kiked the heck out of T55 and T62 mainly, not T34...

 

[rocco]

if no upgrades, then the sherman was just a inflamable can with a locust gun for its main armament... compare it this way, a watch made in switzerland vs a watch made in china.

 

[Aguy201]

funny