Seals vs. Marines - Page 6




 
--
 
February 14th, 2004  
Redneck
 
 
I beg your pardon, I thought we had answered your question:

Quote:
Delta is the elite of the Green Berets, Delta guys usually only do one tour as such and then return to the ranks of the Green Berets. I think that this makes them more elite than the SEALS and Green Berets, but again this opens up the question of what it means to be elite and the problem of comparing diverse groups again, so I'm just going to leave it as my opinion.

Like I said, this is my opinion, and although I believe it is justified, I'm sure someone will disagree with me, but there's your answer.
And there's no need to get snippy, mate.
February 14th, 2004  
Anonymous
 
The 1st Special Forces Operational Detachment Delta (SFOD-D), or Delta Force, is a unit tasked with counter-terrorist(ism) operations outside of the US. Delta (also referred to as Combat Applications Group) is reported to train extensively in CQB (Close Quarters Battle), including airplane, bus and train scenarios. They recruit from all branches of the US Army. Passing the Q course (SFQC) is a requirement so they are SF qual'd. In terms of being "more elite" there's no answer, each SOF unit is formed for specific tasks in mind, sometimes they overlap - but essentially they have different jobs.

Calling an SF soldier a "green beret" is typically considered offensive.
February 15th, 2004  
diplomatic_means
 
So in essence Delta Force is like tom Clancy's Rainbow Six group right? They are specialized counterterrorism unit. The FBI Hostage Rescue team I know is considered Special Forces so how do they compare assignment wise and training wise to Delta Force?
--
February 16th, 2004  
Anonymous
 
Yes, they specialise in counter-terrosism operations. No, they are nothing like Tom Clancy anything. The FBI HRT is not "Special Forces." The only "Special Forces" within the United States is the US Army Special Forces.
The FBI HRT trains in CT and HR and are a full time team, which makes them more specialised than the FBI's SWAT teams - but are capable of performing your average SWAT duties as well, obviously. They often train with the military and other federal and sometimes local civilian tactical teams. Their selection process is about two weeks, training after is about 4 months and one has to have been a special agent with the FBI for 3 years before even applying. (I'm about 95% sure that's correct, but you can always check on the FBI website to make sure) When not deployed (CONUS) they train full-time. So, you can tell right away the initial selection and initial training time is much shorter than that of military SOF units. A lot of things are different, these guys are federal law enforcement, not military .. so there are going to be different SOPs and a different mindset. I've trained and worked with them a few times, and they are very good, but it's really hard to compare a law enforcement agency to a military unit.
February 16th, 2004  
FutureRANGER
 
 
Read Black Hawk Down, the book by Mark Bowden on which the movie was primarily based. It will tell you a lot about SFs and especially Delta. Darn good book too.
February 16th, 2004  
Anonymous
 
Black Hawk Down is a good book, but it's not the most reliable source for specific information. It was written as an account of an event, not really anything more. The book is well written and did more justice to the Mog guys than any other book written, blew Hackworth's feeble attempt out of the water, but obviously, it left out some things that just couldn't be put in. And it must be remembered, Bowden worked with what he had on all levels. Which in the case of SFOD-D, was one, and only one, ex operator - so, much of that information was not always completely accurate nor representative.
February 17th, 2004  
USMC-Taylor
 
compared to the Army the Marine Corp is much smaller branch of military but the marines are fierce and i mean fierce fighters,

SEALS, compared to Marines, Much easier to get in the Marines because training is not as nearly as tough as the SEALs training.. for the SEALs think about 7 months of pure HELL i gues you can almost say the same for the Marines

overall you cant compare the two branches of military, because they are totally different branches all together
February 17th, 2004  
No MERCY
 
 

Topic: Fight


Yes, but don't they both fight. Don't they risk their lives. the trainning might be different but in actuallity. They all have the same job. That's to protect the United States. Each one has a thing or two that they are good at.
February 20th, 2004  
JaegerWolf08
 
 
Like I said before, each unit has distinct missions, and operating styles. They are apples and oranges. Both may be fruit but they are completely different from each other. SEALs are badass, Recon Marines are badass, and SF guys are badass, they each have a different mission, but are all working towards the same goal.
March 6th, 2004  
Theo1
 
My brother was a Seal ( team 3 ) in Coronado. He told me that Delta Force was a project that failed. I'm not an expert on the military or anything, but I think some of you are incorrect in your claim that Seals only work in water areas. I know my brother received desert, snow, and jungle training. Also, he stated all Special Forces do basically the same kind of work. But he did emphasize that Seal training is the most difficult and intense anywhere. 60-70% either drop out or are kicked out. How many of you know about Seal Team Six? After hearing the stories my brother told me, I can state with absolute assurance that the Seals are the badest of the badest! They're the ultimate warriors. The deadliest men on planet earth. Trust me.