India chooses European fighters over US/Russian rivals

April 30th, 2011  

Topic: India chooses European fighters over US/Russian rivals


Soure: BBC

India has shortlisted two European fighter jets, ruling out two US rivals for a key $11bn (6.6bn) military contract.

The Indian defence ministry picked the pan-European Eurofighter and France-based Dessault's Rafale ahead of jets made by Boeing and Lockheed Martin.

The US ambassador in India said the US was "deeply disappointed" by the news.

President Barack Obama had personally lobbied on behalf of the US defence contractors, as had European leaders.

"It is confirmed Eurofighter and Rafale have been selected and the remaining four are off," said the Indian defence ministry.

The other two companies to miss out were Sweden's Saab and the Russian makers of the MiG 35.
'Political setback'

The ambassador, Timothy Roemer, said: "We are reviewing the documents received from the government of India and are respectful of the procurement process."

He added that the US "looked forward to continuing to grow and develop our defence partnership with India".

However, some commentators suggested there could be some political fallout from the decision.

"The Americans will be very unhappy and people who have been backing the contract will say India has not sufficiently taken into account the political relationship with the US," said former Indian foreign secretary Kanwal Sibal.

"That is a political setback for relations."

Mr Roemer announced separately that he was resigning from his post for "personal, professional and family considerations".
Big spenders

A report published last month said that India had overtaken China to become the world's largest importer of arms.

The Stockholm International Peace Research Institute said India accounted for 9% of all weapons imports between 2006 and 2010.

With a $32.5bn (19.5bn) defence budget, India imports more than 70% of its arms.

The $11bn deal for 126 fighter jets is part of plan to spend $50bn over the next five years on modernising its armed forces.
May 3rd, 2011  
Its going to be close.

One one hand, India already has older French fighters (Mirage) so adapting the Rafale would be easier as a lot of the Air Force infrastructure stays the same.

The Rafale also has more combat experience.

On the other hand, the Rafale tends to be more expensive. The higher price point has cost Dessault other contracts in other countries.
May 6th, 2011  

Topic: Re: India chooses European fighters over US/Russian rivals

This will be interesting but, even more interesting will be the reasons the winner is chosen? The real reasons for choosing the winner will not be disclosed for awhile.

Similar Topics
understanding between china and india
Indians are so treacherous -- Richard Nixon
India, China seek to resolve boundary dispute