If the China communist army attack Taiwan, would the west countries protect Taiwan?




 
--
 
February 26th, 2013  
udaka
 

Topic: If the China communist army attack Taiwan, would the west countries protect Taiwan?


As a Chinese , I want to ask a question. If the China communist army attack Taiwan, as a people of west countries, will you sacrifice your live to protect Taiwan?
Because according
< the Taiwan Relations Act.> The USA or Nato perhaps involve the war against China. Many people would die or wounded in the war.

As a people of west countries, will you sacrifice your live to protect Taiwan? did the USA owe Taiwanese many thing? Don't talk me any sh!t protect or help Taiwan is for " democracy or freedom". What benifits did the west countries can got from support Taiwan?
February 26th, 2013  
udaka
 
Sorry,I don't know other people idea or thinking, But my life only die for my country ,my families and the good person who ever save me.
I never shed my blood for some person that I have no relationship.
February 26th, 2013  
Capt Frogman
 
 
You say you'd die for your country?

So would many soldiers "from the west" if their country went to war with China over Taiwan.
--
February 26th, 2013  
LeEnfield
 
 
During many wares other counties have fought and died for places that were not theres. As China is claiming many places these days as a part of historical Chinese terrority you could wind up fighting and dieing for places you have never heard off
February 27th, 2013  
udaka
 
But I think USA politicain wound't send their man and women in army to die in a place irrelevant their country and territory,perhaps they only condemn China when Chinese recover Taiwan.


If the USA politician don't care poeple or soldiers lives, send them to many battlefields irrelevant their country. let the American die at there. I think nobody willing become the tools of these dirty politicians. Who care the dirty politician what they said and do.
February 27th, 2013  
udaka
 
So ,what west countries get from defend Taiwan?

If American government said they support Taiwan because the Taiwan island Strategic location is very important .
Then I can tell you: The Philippines island or the Vietnam ,Myanmar,their Strategic location are more important than Taiwan island. If China capture these location and build a militarybase on it, they would much important than Taiwan island.

I said I die for my country only refer justify war, not a evil war. I oppose China invade and massacre people of other countries under condition no reason and no threat. I will reject join the army if China government do these. Just like many American refuse service the army during the Vietnam war.

IF, I only said "if" the USA politician plan sacrifice 60-80 millions American lives ,for the reason conquer the world,launch a big war even a nuclear war. I think all the American citizens would against the war, even overturn evil government of USA.





Quote:
Originally Posted by Capt Frogman
You say you'd die for your country?

So would many soldiers "from the west" if their country went to war with China over Taiwan.
February 27th, 2013  
Capt Frogman
 
 
Well if China was stupid enough to attack Taiwan, the US won't just sit back and watch.
February 27th, 2013  
brinktk
 
 
What people fail to realize is just how fragile the Chinese government and economy is right now. The US wouldn't even have to go to war, economic and diplomatic sanctions would absolutely cripple the growth of the Chinese economy. Once that goes, famine isn't too far behind. We wouldn't have to launch one bomb or land one soldier for MILLIONS of Chinese to be killed from starvation or overwork. China is MUCH more dependent on the global market than the global market is dependent on China.
The CCP knows this and isn't going to do anthing until they can get at least regional overmatch of UN/NATO forces in air/land/sea capability for any planned invasion. This is still many many years away from being a reality.
February 27th, 2013  
udaka
 
Don't you know the power will change with times pass out, the Soviet union wasn't a big power when he founded in 1917, but after Stalin and other soviet union leader develope industry and economic, Soviet become a superpower at 1960s,-1980s. you claim ccp had no enough navy and air force invade Taiwan before 30 years ago, no represent China had no ability in the furture. The power will change with times ,Just like some global big power decline very fast in the history,like British emprie and soviet union.

You claim war will lead to China famine,made me curiosity. Don't you know China provide foods for himself since 1949, Yes, China import many crops in recent years, but just for feed animals,Because we want eat more meat.
And, with China one-child policy execution for 30 years. half of Chinese families only had one child ,maybe some families have two chlid, the total population of China will decline after 2015, at that time we won't worry about the foods . But the west company can't exploit so-call "cheap- labours " in China, Because our salary will raise serval times than now.

At here we don't discuss the question about military power, just ask will you shed your blood for some people had no relationship with you.

Quote:
Originally Posted by brinktk
What people fail to realize is just how fragile the Chinese government and economy is right now. The US wouldn't even have to go to war, economic and diplomatic sanctions would absolutely cripple the growth of the Chinese economy. Once that goes, famine isn't too far behind. We wouldn't have to launch one bomb or land one soldier for MILLIONS of Chinese to be killed from starvation or overwork. China is MUCH more dependent on the global market than the global market is dependent on China.
The CCP knows this and isn't going to do anthing until they can get at least regional overmatch of UN/NATO forces in air/land/sea capability for any planned invasion. This is still many many years away from being a reality.
February 27th, 2013  
udaka
 
Many people claim USA support Taiwanese because Taiwan islands very important. I can't see what important of Taiwan island. Like someones said Taiwan is very close to China mainland, if USA bulit a military base on it, its air force and Tomahawk cruise missiles can attack China mainland very easy. But the USA had militarybases on South korean and Japan,they are close to China geographically,so the USA don't need Taiwan any longer.


And in nuclear age, China nuclear submarines don't need pass Taiwan to entry pacific sea. If ccp will , they can built navy base at North korean,Pakistan.

And if the human being built space battleships who carry the nuclear warheads patrol the solar system, nuclear strike the Eath just serval minutes. So China don't need Taiwan as militarybase at all.

Sure ,as a human being, I avoid the ideas the global nuclear war outbreak absolutely.That mean the humanity will go to extinction.
 


Similar Topics
"Tommy's Dictionary Of The Trenches" WWI
Why can't Taiwanese people accept their Chinese heritage?
China' army
Japanese military and politic -- Discussion and details.
How to stop China