How To: Run an ‘Honesty Trace’ to Counter Roadside Bombs

Xeric

New Member
How To: Run an ‘Honesty Trace’ to Counter Roadside Bombs | Danger Room | Wired.com


How To: Run an ‘Honesty Trace’ to Counter Roadside Bombs

Roadside bombs remain the number-one threat to U.S. and coalition forces in Afghanistan. But as Noah recently reported, one Marine officer has forwarded an ingenious, off-the-shelf method for avoiding natural ambush points: The “honesty trace.”

Former Wall Street Journal reporter Matt Pottinger — now a Marine Corps first lieutenant — came up with the idea while working with Combat Logistics Battalion 3 in Helmand Province. The idea was simple: Pottinger hooked up the unit’s vehicles with commercial GPS trackers to create a digital record of the routes they were driving. Then he overlaid the routes to see where tracks were converging. It turned out that terrain often forced the Marines into natural chokepoints where the Taliban could set up ambushes.

Changing up routes is standard in military operations, but creating “honesty traces” (a term borrowed from the British in Northern Ireland, who did the same thing with tracing paper) can help troops avoid falling into unexpected — and potentially deadly — patterns. This unclassified briefing — prepared for the 2nd Marine Expeditionary Brigade, but also for other International Security Assistance Force units — doesn’t involve much more than a Garmin GPS, a USB port and Excel spreadsheets.

“Honesty traces plainly tell us which wadi crossings we gravitate toward, which stretches of desert we have traversed before, and which contours and chokepoints we and our sister units tend to repeatedly navigate,” the briefing states. “Hence, the traces keep us honest.”
 
This is not bad but soldiers are already going to know these chokepoints. The intel section of a Bn is going to have every IED gone off and every firefight recorded and plotted on a map. Troops are going to know everything that is happening in their battle space. Exception of course happen say if a unit is pulling convoy security for KBR at long distances or if they are changing AO's.

Often times they are well beyond simply knowing where firefights and IEDs have occured. They will have headcounts of villages and recognize people who do not reside there. They will notice subtle changes in terrain and landmarks such as cars or trash cans that are not where they normaly are. There are many others things that are done to prevent and recognize threats.
 
True but this is one of many bags of tricks.
The goal is to have a simple way to anticipate where the IEDs will be.
Sometimes we think we're being random but if we anayze our actual movement, it turns out that we're indeed making a pattern.
Especially useful if you're headed towards territory that's not often travelled or perhaps places that you have just deployed to.
 
I concur with Big Z, chokepoints are known but in some cases have to be defeated.

A few units have been doing this for a while. Esp scout and/or spearhead elements handing AO,s off to others.

//KJ.
 
While it is a good idea, there no substitute for situational awareness. If you have a trooper bogged down with a bunch of things to watch, then someone less technologically advanced armed with, say, a stone axe, is going to win everytime.
However, every tool has a use, and it could just save one more life. Sounds like a good tool, just not the final solution.
 
Pretty useless. The troops know where the IED's are but the Generals send them through the same areas regardless.
 
Back
Top