Grade your Military Report Cards.




 
--
Boots
 
March 21st, 2005  
Red_Army
 
 

Topic: Grade your Military Report Cards.


Here are the top 10 Military Powers of the World. You will give a grade from a A, B, C+, C, C-, and F.

USA
Army A
Airforce A
Navy A

China
Army A
Airforce C+
Navy C-

India
Army A
Airforce C
Navy C

United Kingdom
Army A
Airforce B
Navy C+

Japan
Army B
Airforce B
Navy B

North Korea
Army A
Airforce C-
Navy C

South Korea
Army A
Airforce B
Navy B

Russia
Army B
Airforce C+
Navy C-

Pakistan
Army C+
Airforce C
Navy F

Taiwan
Army B
Airforce B
Navy C+
March 21st, 2005  
Charge 7
 
 
My military report card says: "very active in sports, plays well with others, very vocal in class."
March 21st, 2005  
03USMC
 
 
Wheres the Marine Corps?
--
Boots
March 22nd, 2005  
Kilgore
 
Im amazed how you graded the north korean army and navy higher than Russia's. Russia is stronger than you may think.

i would grade russia like this:
Army: B+
Airforce: B
Navy: C

As for china, i wouldn't grade its army as A. Same with india.
March 22nd, 2005  
Xion
 
India
Army: A
Air Force: B
Navy: C+

China
Army: A
AirForce: B-
Navy: C

Russia
Army: B
Air Force: B
Navy: B+
March 22nd, 2005  
Knightraptor
 
I think the North Korean grading may need some evaluation...
March 22nd, 2005  
A Can of Man
 
 
The NK Army is definately not a grade A army.
Their special operations wing is, but the rest of their army is rather lousy.
March 23rd, 2005  
Vitaly
 
I feel that the Russian Army is being underrated.
March 23rd, 2005  
CABAL
 
 
Quote:
United Kingdom
Army A
Airforce B
Navy C+
First of all, the Royal Navy still remains as world class Navy. Deserves to receieve a A- instead.

United Kingdom
Army A
Airforce B
Navy A-

Quote:
North Korea
Army A
Airforce C-
Navy C
The Army is over-rated. The airforce again is overrated. The Navy too is overrated.

North Korea
Army B-
Airforce D
Navy D

Quote:
Russia
Army B
Airforce C+
Navy C-
I concur that Russia is being underrated. I've given the Navy a C+ because of poor conditions of the Soviet Era Hulls due to budget constraints. Although the Russians were able to create fabulous demonstration weapons, many of them were not fielded or purchased by the Russian Military.

Russia
Army A
Airforce B
Navy C+

Quote:
Pakistan
Army C+
Airforce C
Navy F
Red Army, you have underestimated Pakistan's abilities. The Pakistani Army is very well equipped and well trained to suit their abilities to conduct missions.

Pakistan
Army B
Airforce C
Navy D+

Quote:
China
Army A
Airforce C+
Navy C-
Certainly the Army is A I quite agree. However the Airforce is still below western air forces in terms of technology but it's effectiveness comes from the sheer numbers of combat aircraft they have. The Navy are in better conditions because of the surge of new ships PLAN have just recently acquired and are scrapping old ships.

The People's Republic of China
Army A
Airforce B
Navy B-

Quote:
India
Army A
Airforce C
Navy C
I think you too have overrated the Indian Army because there are many concerns regarding to technical issues with the weapons they use. Second of all India is not considered to be a land power like China and Russia. The Airforce is quite exceptional although they are still in the same shoes as China. Naval capabilities are somewhat the main reasons India became a Regional power in South East Asia.

India
Army B+
Airforce B
Navy B

I actually can't believe you have left out Germany, France, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Israel, South Africa. How about these nations?
March 23rd, 2005  
Xion
 
Quote:
Naval capabilities are somewhat the main reasons India became a Regional power in South East Asia.
India is a South Asian country...doesn't belong to south east asia

India doesn't have much influence over South East Asia except in the Bay of Bengal region ..countries like Myanmar and western Indonesia

The South Asian countries are Pakistan, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Bhutan, Nepal, Maldives
All the above nations combined cannot match neither the amount nor the quality of india's armed forces
Now, i don't quite know what made you say only because of the Naval power India could become a regional power....


Quote:
Second of all India is not considered to be a land power like China and Russia
With the second largest army after China I don't quite agree with that.

I don't quite know how are you ppl grading these militaries...based on effective strength in a war ?...or based on the quality of equipment , training .etc ?

If you are grading them based on all the factors combined...then I don't agree with this --

Quote:
UK
Army A

India
Army B+
UK might have better equipment ...but the number is way too small to face a massive army
UK's main strength being an island nation lies in its navy
India's main strength lies in its army...doesn't face any naval threat like China (from Japan), etc..

Also I think you ppl are underestimating North Korea's navy with a D class grading.