Topic: Why?

U.S. Cavalry

FAQ/Rules - Search - Military Photo Gallery

  International Military Forums > Military Discussion Forums > Political Discussions
User Name
Password

 
June 8th, 2006   Post 1
SNowblind
Immunes
 
Gear

Post; Why?


Why aren't there any books/movies/games that I know of that have a German perspective of WW2?

it is understandable to not have anything from the SS/Nazi point of view, but the Wermacht wasn't evil per se, just following orders. It would be REALLY interesting to have a movie of the germans perspective of the Russian front, or D day/battle of the bulge.

closest thing I have seen is "Enemy at the Gates."
 
June 8th, 2006   Post 2
KC72
Tribuni Angusticlavii
 
 
Gear

there are, you just have to look a bit harder, there's the Sven Hassel books and Cross of Iron is a decent film.
__________________
 
June 8th, 2006   Post 3
AussieNick
Forum Digger
 
 
Gear

I believe there is one called "stalingrad" from the German point of view.
And for WW1, there is all quiet on the western front.

But he... look at it the way, the victors of war get more benifits than just "winning". They influence the way history and society views the loser.
__________________
Platoon Commander, 4 Platoon, B Company
10/27th Battalion RSAR - RAinf

PRO PATRIA
 
June 9th, 2006   Post 4
gladius
Primus Pilus
 
There was a computer game called "Panzer General", you played the part of a German general like Guderian, or Manstien comanding the Wermacht and blitzing Europe.

It was so popular they ended up extending it to "Panzer General III".
 
June 9th, 2006   Post 5
bulldogg
Milforum's Bouncer
 
 
Gear


U-571 for a movie or Das Boot.
For a game try Close Combat you can play any side you want.
__________________
"The purpose of fighting is to win. There is no possible victory in defense. The sword is more important than the shield and skill is more important than either. The final weapon is the brain. All else is supplemental." - John Steinbeck
 
June 9th, 2006   Post 6
Rabs
Tribuni Angusticlavii
 
 
Plus theres the whole thing, that youd have to change history in the game and that would just make things complicated. Cause after the first "level" youd have to make everything up.
__________________
 
June 10th, 2006   Post 7
The Cooler King
Godfather
 
Gear

There are tons and tons of books out there from the German perspective. As far as movies go, look for Das Boot, Stalingrad, Cross of Iron, Die Brucke, The Eagle has Landed, and Der Untergang.
 
June 10th, 2006   Post 8
Ted
Tribunus Laticlavius
 
 
Gear

Quote:
Originally Posted by The Cooler King
There are tons and tons of books out there from the German perspective. As far as movies go, look for Das Boot, Stalingrad, Cross of Iron, Die Brucke, The Eagle has Landed, and Der Untergang.
I reckon you covered the movies properly with these. I personally think that Sven Hassel wrote his books too much as a novel. If war were that easy, well hell, what are we waiting for. My personal favourite book would be The forgotten Soldier written by Guy Sajer. He was a Alsatian Frenchman fighting in the Gross Deutschland..... it is really something!
 
June 10th, 2006   Post 9
godofthunder9010
Tribunus Laticlavius
 
 
Gear

Quote:
Originally Posted by SNowblind
Why aren't there any books/movies/games that I know of that have a German perspective of WW2?

it is understandable to not have anything from the SS/Nazi point of view, but the Wermacht wasn't evil per se, just following orders. It would be REALLY interesting to have a movie of the germans perspective of the Russian front, or D day/battle of the bulge.

closest thing I have seen is "Enemy at the Gates."
The problem with this is that, as a rule, the people of Germany simply don't talk about World War II at any length. For one thing, this is because most are ashamed of what their nation did with extermination camps of various sorts. There's just a lot of shame, period.

I did find a lot of books that told it from the German perspective whilst doing a research paper in college. One good one would be "Panzer Leader" by Heinz Guderian. Not a Nazi, but very involved in the war ... just like most most members of the German military. I had to find the English translation on Inter-Library Loan because there aren't a lot of copies out there. But there was a better general perspective that I found. I just can't remember the name of the book or the author.

PM Doppleganger, he'd know more than most people here. Of course, this question would probably be better place in the WW2 forum, since that is where Dopp is always hanging around at.
__________________
"It is well that war is so terrible, else we should grow too fond of it."
- General Robert E. Lee
Warning, critical pebkac error in the iD10t!! pebkac\wtflolurpwnzd\snafuroflmao.exe called iD10t, iD10t failed to respond!! System in danger!!

"It takes a big man to admit when he's wrong. I am NOT a big man." -Chevy Chase
 
June 17th, 2006   Post 10
Ace
Optio
 
Gear

Winners define history.....