April 24th, 2010
|
#6 |
|
| Quote: |
Originally Posted by redcoat He didn't burn a fort ( they were made out of thick stone, not wood) he captured it and spiked its guns.
Indeed. 
Don't get me wrong, John Paul Jones was a brave and daring man who fully deserves his place amongst American hero's. I'm just correcting the folk-lore surrounding this incident | Actually, it was a surprizing raid for the time. I think the descrption from the History channel link I gave might be more accurate. But anyway yours seems to romantize it better. And Jones is credited in doing the Brittish a favor: "So ended the attack on Whitehaven of 1778. In truth, despite being audacious, having the advantage of surprise and Jones’s inside knowledge, the attack had been a bungled failure. This seems to have been due largely to the American crew’s reluctance to "destroy poor peoples property" as Wallingford had put it. However, the shock waves, that it sent throughout the country were completely out of proportion with the mere few hundred pounds worth of damage actually caused and turned John Paul Jones into an infamous pirate. Importantly, it awakened everyone to the threat of invasion. The defences of not only Whitehaven but also the entire British coast were improved and more volunteers joined the militias. In short, John Paul Jones did Britain a favour because his actions probably prevented a full-scale French invasion." |
|
| |