| |
| | Post 21 |
| Centurion | I read it and liked it and the most facinating thing is, that he wrote it so long ago and most of the things were usefull till today.
__________________ \"I am a soldier, I fight where I am told, and I win where I fight.\" -- General George S. Patton |
| |
| | Post 22 |
| Immunes | I like the book because out of all the older military stagedy books I have read it makes the most sense. Most armies of that day beleived strength against strength was the way to go instead of surgical strikes against weak positions and using espinoige to maximize the most out of the situation. (sorry if I mispell I am on a public computer so the spell check doesn't work)
__________________ And when he gets to heaven, To Saint Peter he will tell: One more soldier reporting, sir-- I\'ve served my time in h**l. -Marine Grave inscription on Guadalcanal, 1942 |
| |
| | Post 23 |
| Centurion | Little trivia on the Art of War. Taoisim considers the Art of War a religious text. One of my mates studies Taoisim in great detail and that just came up in a conversation. Bet most of youse didn't know that
__________________ "Even if I wished to surrender to you - and I don't - I am commanding Australian's who would cut my throat if I accepted your Terms" Colonel C Hore, Siege of Elands River, 1900 If You want to See the Future, Read a History Book |
| |
| | Post 24 |
| Milforum Swamp Dweller | Sun Tzu, exaggerated? To some, yes. However, his emphasis on creating friction is the factor that makes a great offensive army. IMHO, Clausewitz wasn't as good a tactician as SunTzu, as most of his efforts were geared towards defense (i.e. reducing friction) |
| |
| | Post 25 |
| Milforum Chaplain | It is only one who is thoroughly acquainted with the evils of war that can thoroughly understand the profitable way of carrying it on. (ch II) - regrettably true. |
| |
| | Post 26 |
| Milforum Gnat | Any idea where I can find an online copy of Sun Tzu Bing Fa? btw, Sun Tzu's father, or is it his son?, Sun Bing also wrote a military tactics. You should read about it and compare the methods used!
__________________ - Ready To Strike - |
| |
| | Post 27 |
| MilForum Bad Apple | Post; Sun Tzu no Rocket Scientist.The Art of War is a very good book, but, a second grader could read it and comprehend it. It's common sense most of it. -Always have the high ground. -Attack where the enemy isn't inspecting. -Attack the weakest Flank. -Diversions. Basic stuff here folks. The Prince, is another book of equal proportion, a much better read in my opinion. If you dont no who it's by then... -FMJ-
__________________ "For Democracy, any man would give his only begotten son." |
| |
| | Post 28 | |
| Milites Gregarius | Quote:
Amateurs read Sun Tzu. Professionals think Sun Tzu. As for the Prince I have to agree with you with greatness,but not on equal par with Sun Tzu.The author Machiavelli is no doubt a political genius,but Sun Tzu would do things that Machiavelli would consider low and dishonorable. So if you compare those two ,I believe Sun Tzu would win. I'm not trying to demote the worth of The Prince as a matter of fact it's one of my favorite books and I read it at every opportunity,the things that Machiavelli states are things that I would have never even thought of in a million years,but when it comes up against Eastern philosophy it just doesn't cut it.
__________________ "It is a good viewpoint to see the world as a dream. When you have something like a nightmare, you will wake up and tell yourself that it was only a dream. It is said that the world we live in is not a bit different from this." -Hagakure | |
| |
| | Post 29 |
| Milforum Gnat | Any idea where can I find that book? The Prince? Is it a strategy guide? |
| |
| | Post 30 | |
| Milites Gregarius | Quote:
It's a book on politics written by the political genius Niccolo Machiavelli.It advocates on how to rule a country with relative ease and dominate the political battleground. Although many of the things mentioned in the book are now associated with Tolitarian Dictatorships. You can find it in any bookstore. | |
| |