I know its off topic but seeing as we are onto the usual bullpup v standard debate how come no-one has used helical magazines in an assault rifle?

Originally Posted by sven hassell

I know its off topic but seeing as we are onto the usual bullpup v standard debate how come no-one has used helical magazines in an assault rifle?

They provide a good amount of ammo on tap, but it also makes reloads slow and clumsy. They also have a lot of problems when they're exposed to mud, dirt and sand. I don't think they would work very well on an assault rifle, with the size and length they would have to be, it would seem to me they would wear very quickly, especially the spring. Then there's the added weight and reload time. Just not very ergonomic, I would think.

We have C-mags, but they're pretty much worthless with all of the problems they have. They look cool for pictures though, so sometimes we'll bring them out when doing dog and pony shows.

Helical? this is the first time I heard of it! Any one care to explain?

http://world.guns.ru/smg/smg57-e.htm

This page should have all the info you need on helical magazines.

Thanks!