Topic: Impact of Movies 2

U.S. Cavalry

FAQ/Rules - Search - Military Photo Gallery

  International Military Forums > Military Discussion Forums > Military Books and Movies Forum
User Name
Password

 
March 27th, 2007   Post 11
doomshot
Immunes
 
 
Yes that is true. luckily war is so terrible, or else we would grow too fond of it. I'm looking for things that made the public feel that it is necessary to fight this war, such as when Corporal York was made in sometime between 1940-1943 as an attempt to show that you can still be a good Christian and be a soldier and was used as a type of recruiting tool , or made them believe that the war is too terrible to have ever sent our people there such as in the Deer Hunter when they were tortured and the characters made to play Russian Roulette by the Viet Cong. I'm sorry if any know better than I and knows whether or not I am actually misquoting the the movies.
__________________
And when he gets to heaven,
To Saint Peter he will tell:
One more soldier reporting, sir--
I\'ve served my time in h**l.
-Marine Grave inscription on Guadalcanal, 1942

Last edited by doomshot; March 27th, 2007 at 23:47.
 
March 28th, 2007   Post 12
KJ
Centurion
 
 
Nobody wants to go to war.
If a war never the less comes down the pike there are various degrees of willingness to fight that war.
There are the people that feel it´s their duty to be first in, there are people dodging until they get called upon and there are people that dodge it all together.
IMO only the ones that have not seen a wartorn nation would ever concider a war anything then a last resort.

So to answer your original question. NO, so called warmovies does not make people want to go to war.
To answer your second question. Seeing the towers go down would be enough for me to bring it home that this one was the last resort and make my blood boil.

Those are my answers to your as I see them two different questions.

Just my two cents (and well worth what you paid for them).
__________________
"We are the pilgrims, Master
We shall go always a little further,
it may be beyond the last blue mountain barred with snow,
Across that angry or glimmering sea..."
 
July 6th, 2007   Post 13
deerslayer
Milforum Swamp Dweller
 
 
Gear

I agree with KJ. Nobody, unless absolutely forced to, likes a fistfight or an argument. War is a totally different being entirely- it is wholesale killing at its finest- government-sanctioned violence. It is the absolute last diplomatic option of a country; I'm no peacenik by any standard but I believe it is not something to be taken lightly at all.

Anyone who's ever considered joining, myself included, has to consider the moral and ethical possibilities of warfare and come to grips with that beforehand. However, I have to consider the words of Sgt. Matt Eversmann: "I don't believe that there is anyone who hasn't wanted, in some way, to go to war."

Do the very good films depict a skewed version of combat? I didn't notice anything skewed about Black Hawk Down- the men there have earned their lionization, and with a good PR department they could possibly be a recruiting tool.
__________________
Screwing over bureaucratic organizations, one paper tiger at a time.

Trespassers will be shot and fed to the dogs.
 



Similar Threads
Opponents Of Nevada Bomb Test Fault Impact Studies
Impact Of Police Being Sent To Iraq Felt On Street
Favorite War Movies...
CAP planes assessing hurricane’s impact in FL
History Channel. HistoryChannel.com movies