Topic: American deserter from N Korea 2

SHERMAN · August 12th, 2004

I m,ust say, that I dislike the whole idea of puting people to death, but there are a few exeptions, and desertion in times of war is one of them. line him up against the closest wall.

LIPS · August 12th, 2004

Well, well there are a few vigilantes out there amoungst us arent there?? I would think a FAIR trail in front of his peers should be conducted before we condemn this man to death. I just thought thats what our nations strived for or are striving for in past and present conflicts.

What are the facts behind this case?? I dont know?? But before we make a decision lets just look for the FACTS and TRUTHS and not just what is put in the media.

I dont condone what he may have done in the past but we all come from free nations that do have a just and fair legal systems and they should be used to punish this man if thats what is required.

Lets not have a Mob mentality lets instead use a little thing called justice.

silent driller · August 12th, 2004

Quote:

Originally Posted by scott.moore

Well, well there are a few vigilantes out there amoungst us arent there?? I would think a FAIR trail in front of his peers should be conducted before we condemn this man to .

THEN line him up on the nearest wall

Uncle_Sam · August 12th, 2004

I say: Shoot the bastard!

FlyingFrog · August 12th, 2004

I say lave him ALONE.

It is already so long time ago, he is so eldly, show some mercy, don't push too hard.

And I believe NOTHING will happen with this old gentleman, mark my word can check it after 2 years

1217 · August 13th, 2004

I don't think his age or motives have anything to do with it. He broke the law, I say he should be tried.

Uncle_Sam · August 13th, 2004

Quote:

Originally Posted by FlyingFrog

I say lave him ALONE.

It is already so long time ago, he is so eldly, show some mercy, don't push too hard.

And I believe NOTHING will happen with this old gentleman, mark my word can check it after 2 years

What would You say if some deserter from PLA in the let's say China US , or China Russian,war gone into our side... And after he wanted to come back!?

He should be at least hanged.........

cPFC/SAJROTC · August 13th, 2004

I think he should be arrested and sent back here to the US to stand trial for what he did. From what I read, it doesn't sound like he was some poor Pvt who was drafted into work and fled, he was a leader and set a bad example. Plus he defected to a country that has had poor relations before and now with the US.

He deserves to be punished for what he did, he needs to be extradited

GuyontheRight · August 13th, 2004

Punish Him, lets set an example.

Intelligal · August 14th, 2004

I agree

Line him up at the nearest wall

August 12th, 2004	Post 11
SHERMAN Milforum Moderator Gear	I m,ust say, that I dislike the whole idea of puting people to death, but there are a few exeptions, and desertion in times of war is one of them. line him up against the closest wall. __________________

August 12th, 2004	Post 12
LIPS Tribuni Angusticlavii	Well, well there are a few vigilantes out there amoungst us arent there?? I would think a FAIR trail in front of his peers should be conducted before we condemn this man to death. I just thought thats what our nations strived for or are striving for in past and present conflicts. What are the facts behind this case?? I dont know?? But before we make a decision lets just look for the FACTS and TRUTHS and not just what is put in the media. I dont condone what he may have done in the past but we all come from free nations that do have a just and fair legal systems and they should be used to punish this man if thats what is required. Lets not have a Mob mentality lets instead use a little thing called justice. __________________ Some more words of wisdom from LIPS

August 12th, 2004	Post 14
Uncle_Sam Centurion	I say: Shoot the bastard! __________________ American Military Community

August 12th, 2004	Post 15
FlyingFrog Tribuni Angusticlavii	I say lave him ALONE. It is already so long time ago, he is so eldly, show some mercy, don't push too hard. And I believe NOTHING will happen with this old gentleman, mark my word can check it after 2 years __________________ From Corporals to Generals. Rising Dragons of Middle Kingdom. http://s3.invisionfree.com/PLA_MILIT...TURE/index.php

August 13th, 2004	Post 16
1217 Primus Pilus	I don't think his age or motives have anything to do with it. He broke the law, I say he should be tried. __________________ "It is not supreme excellence to fight and conquer in all your battles, It is supreme excellence if you break the enemy's resistance without fighting." Sun Tzu, the Art of War

August 13th, 2004	Post 18
cPFC/SAJROTC Immunes	I think he should be arrested and sent back here to the US to stand trial for what he did. From what I read, it doesn't sound like he was some poor Pvt who was drafted into work and fled, he was a leader and set a bad example. Plus he defected to a country that has had poor relations before and now with the US. He deserves to be punished for what he did, he needs to be extradited __________________ \"An army is a team. It lives, eats, sleeps, fights as a team. This individuality stuff is a bunch of b******t.\" -- General George Patton Jr

August 13th, 2004	Post 19
GuyontheRight Tribuni Angusticlavii	Punish Him, lets set an example. __________________ No Voice

August 14th, 2004	Post 20
Intelligal Milites Gregarius	I agree Line him up at the nearest wall