Originally Posted by MontyB

Now you have opened up the "loophole" problem, name one person in any of these offshore prisons (lets say Guantánamo Bay) that has been found guilty of anything?

I have no doubt that Iran, North Korea and China only torture the guilty and even then only for the most justifiable reasons they can make up at the time.

The fact is that torture is like pregnancy you cant just be a little bit pregnant, you are or you aren't.