Market garden would have succeded if it was give the airsupport it needed and proberly deserved "inspite of Montgomeries mistakes" and if General Browning had not decided to ignore recon photos of German Armour in the area. It wasn't a total useless operational idea but only seemed that way due to its failure to achieve all its goals.
Mod edit: Craig, please dont post back to back posts: just edit the previous one if you have to add more. Double posts are against the forum rules, and can lead to being severe spankings from the admin and mods. (and some other stuff...) 
l